Digital loyalty card or paper stamp card? A guide for Surrey businesses
Walk down the high street in Guildford, Woking or Epsom and you will still find plenty of cafes, barbers and takeaways handing out paper stamp cards. They are cheap, everyone understands them and they do bring people back. So is it worth moving to a digital loyalty card, or is the paper version good enough?
This guide sets out the honest pros and cons of each, so you can decide what suits your business.
What a paper stamp card does well
A paper stamp card is about as simple as marketing gets. You print a batch, stamp one at the till and give a reward when the card is full. There is nothing to set up, no technology to go wrong and no monthly cost beyond the printing, and every customer knows how it works.
For a small business with a steady crowd of regulars, that simplicity counts for a lot.
Where paper cards fall short
The problems with paper cards are familiar to anyone who has used one.
Customers lose them, leave them at home or start a new card every few visits.
You have no record of who your regulars are or how often they come in.
You cannot contact card holders, so there is no way to tell them about an offer or a quiet day.
Stamps can be copied, and full cards are easy to fake.
When you change the reward or your branding, you need to reprint the lot.
None of these matter much on their own, but together they mean a paper card mostly rewards people who were coming back anyway.
What a digital loyalty card adds
A digital loyalty card does the same basic job, but it lives in your customer's Apple Wallet or Google Wallet. They add it by scanning a QR code, with no app to download, and you add stamps or points by scanning their card from a phone or tablet at the till.
Because the card is in their phone, a few things change:
It does not get lost. The card is with them every time they visit.
You can see who joins. You know how many card holders you have and how often they come back.
You can send messages. A push message to everyone holding your card costs nothing extra, so you can tell them about a quiet day offer, a new menu or a reward they are close to.
Some messages run themselves. Birthday treats, reward reminders and messages to customers you have not seen for a while can be set up once and left.
Changes are instant. You can update the reward or the design without reprinting anything.
The trade-offs
A digital card is not free. There is a set-up cost and a monthly subscription for the loyalty card platform, so you need to be confident it will bring people back often enough to pay for itself. There is also a small amount of effort at the start, because staff need to know how to scan a card and customers need a reason to join.
It also relies on customers having a smartphone. Most do, but if a lot of your regulars do not, you may want to keep a few paper cards behind the counter while everyone else moves over.
Which businesses suit a digital card
A digital loyalty card works best for businesses where customers come back often and the visits are easy to count. In Surrey that includes:
Coffee shops, cafes and bakeries.
Takeaways and restaurants that deliver menus locally.
Barbers, hair salons, nail bars and beauty salons.
Gyms, studios and car washes.
Independent shops with a regular local crowd.
If your customers only buy from you once or twice a year, a loyalty card of either kind is less likely to make a difference.
How to switch without losing your regulars
If you decide to move over, a gentle switch works best.
Offer to transfer existing stamps onto the new digital card, so nobody loses out.
Give a bonus stamp or a small discount for joining.
Put the QR code on the counter, the till and the window, and ask every customer at the till.
Print the QR code on your flyers and takeaway menus, so new customers can join before their first visit.
Stop handing out new paper cards after a set date, while still honouring the ones already out there.
Using leaflets to grow your card holders
The QR code is what links your loyalty card to the rest of your marketing. A menu or flyer delivered through letterboxes near your shop becomes a way to join your loyalty scheme, not just a one-off advert. If you already use door drop marketing, adding the code costs nothing extra to print, and a separate QR code for each drop shows you how many people joined from it.
Common questions
Do customers need to download an app?
No. The card goes into Apple Wallet or Google Wallet, which come with most smartphones.
Can I keep my paper cards as well?
Yes. You can run both for a while and phase the paper cards out once most of your regulars have moved over.
What does a digital loyalty card cost?
With Leaflet Media, set-up is £197 and optional monthly help is £47 a month. The loyalty card platform is a separate monthly subscription, which we confirm when we quote.
Find out more
Leaflet Media sets up digital loyalty cards for businesses across Surrey and Middlesex, and can print the QR code on your flyers and menus and deliver them door to door. Call 07525 722 427 or email surrey@leaflet-media.co.uk to book a free demo and see a card working on your own phone.
Comments